Montenegrin Journal of Economics

Volume 1 № 1

Click to download full article

Click to open full abstract

Irina Osadchaya

СТОИТ ЛИ ПЕРЕЧИТЫВАТЬ МАРКСА

Article title	СТОИТ ЛИ ПЕРЕЧИТЫВАТЬ МАРКСА
Authors	Irina Osadchaya
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	B14, B24, P16
Abstract	In this article is positively replied on thematic question – if it ought to be back to Marx, accordingly if it is staidly and objectively, from historical distance, consider Marx's theory from the contemporaneously position. On that way it is tried to reply on the question what is real place and role of Marx's economic theory in the history of economic thought.
Key words	Marxism, economic thought, capitalism.
Literature
	Download full article

Andrzej Bolesta

POLITICAL ECONOMY OF INTERNATIONAL ASSISTANCE: ECONOMIC, POLITICAL AND LEGAL CONSTRAINTS TO HUMANITARIAN AID IN SUDAN

Article title	POLITICAL ECONOMY OF INTERNATIONAL ASSISTANCE: ECONOMIC, POLITICAL AND LEGAL CONSTRAINTS TO HUMANITARIAN AID IN SUDAN
Authors	Andrzej Bolesta
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	N17
Abstract	Postoji veliki broj pravnih, političkih i ekonomskih ograničenja za efektivnu humanitarno asistenciju u južnom Sudanu. Žestoki sukobi mogu izgledati kao bitan razlog za neuspijeh u potrebnoj pomoći stanovništvu. Godina 2003. je donijela intenzivirane pregovore između zaraćenih strana sa ciljem okončanja rata. Dogovoreno je da bi južnjački pobunjenici ne samo dijelili vlast sa aktuelnom islamskom vladom, nego bi takođe autonomija mogla da vodi do referenduma o otcjepljenju 2010-te. Godina 2004. i početak 2005. su pokazali, međutim, da je zemlja daleko od toga da postane stabilna. Kriza u Darfuru je dokazala da stanovništvo ostaje ekstremno ranjivo i da se borbe između Arapa i Afrikanaca mogu nastaviti za dugo vremena. Mada bi stalni prekid vatre i konačni mir mogli značajno smanjiti ograničenja u pomaganju sudanskom narodu, razlozi za pomoć neće iščeznuti, pošto će užasni uslovi većine stanovništva, uključujući milione raseljenih, najvjerovatnije i dalje trajati.
Key words
Literature
	Download full article

Neđo Balaban

INTELLIGENCE IN STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT

Article title	INTELLIGENCE IN STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
Authors	Neđo Balaban
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	G11, L86, O32
Abstract	This article describes the software product STRATEG, the product of a complex structure, great possibilities, rich functionalities and complete BSC automation The word STRATEG is not an acronym, but it symbolizes the substance, complex structure and value of the system for decision support system (DSS) in the processes of strategic management. The product is designed and built as a fruit of the long-range project "Decision Support System in Strategic Management".
Key words	Business Intelligence, Strategic Management, Decision Support Systems, Performance, STRATEG, ABSC, Achievements, BSC, Organization.
Literature
	Download full article

Zoltán Baracskai, Jolán Velencei, Viktor Dörfler

REDUCTIVE REASONING

Article title	REDUCTIVE REASONING
Authors	Zoltán Baracskai, Jolán Velencei, Viktor Dörfler
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	L86, O32
Abstract	Today one of the most challenging problems of an organization is how to make the decision taking faster in order to improve efficiency. Excellence resides in the differences of people's tacit knowledge. In Knowledge Management excellence can be achieved if the leader delegates the Routine Decisions to others, while the Original Decisions are taken on basis of tacit knowledge. With Expert System Shell DoctuS, we can reduce the expressed rules to those meta-schemata that actually affect the decision. These metaschemata are derived from a blend of explicit and tacit knowledge. The process of reducing the number rules we call reduction, which is the third kind of reasoning beside deduction and induction. The achievement is that we can get the same decision using the values of fewer attributes. According to our experience the benefits include knowledge discovery in every application (i.e. a part of tacit knowledge is made explicit) and the process of decision taking becomes faster and its cost is reduced.
Key words
Literature	1. Anderson, J.R.: The architecture of cognition. Harvard University Press, Boston, MA (1983). 2. Doctus Knowledge Based System Homepage. URL http://www.doctus.info. Accessed 28 October 2004. 3. Minsky, M.: Why People Think Computers Can't. AI Magazine, Vol. 3 No. 4 (1982). URL http://www.ai.mit.edu/people/minsky/papers/ ComputersCantThink.txt, Accessed 29 October 2004 4. Minsky, M.: Negative Expertise. International Journal of Expert Systems, Vol. 7 No. 1 (1994) 13-19. 5. Neisser, U.: Cognitive Psychology. Meredith Publishing, New York, NY (1967). 6. Polanyi, M.: Personal Knowledge: Towards a Post-Critical Philosophy, Routledge, London (1962). 7. Polanyi, M.: The Tacit Dimension. Peter Smith, Gloucester, MA (1966). 8. Quinlan, J. R. The Induction of Decision Trees, Machine Learning, Vol. 1 No. 1 (1986) 81-106. 9. Ryle, G.: The Concept of Mind. Hutchinson and Co., London (1969). 10. Simon, H.A.: The New Science of Management Decision. Prentice-Hall, New Jersey, NJ (1977). 11. Sveiby, K.E.: The New Organizational Wealth. Berrett-Koehler Publishers, San Francisco, CA (1997).
	Download full article

Veselin Drašković

PARADIGMATIČNOST "NOVE EKONOMIJE"

Article title	PARADIGMATIČNOST "NOVE EKONOMIJE"
Authors	Veselin Drašković
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	A10
Abstract	Challenges, consequences, possibilities and ranges of a "new economics" are large and numerous and, therefore, deserve scientific attention and phenomenological approach, particularly in explaining the character of its paradigm. The work provides some theoretical and practical aspects of the "new economics" as a metaphor that reflects the spirit of postindustrial-informatics era, through the prism of assessing a level of its paradigm. Besides this, there are some answers regarding actual questions about relations between the "new economics" and economic theory, progress, civilization approach, business skill and choice. From a theoretical point of view, this analysis shows that the "new economics" paradigm is not only a discussion subject, but that there are no reliable evidences about its existence. Traditional laws, principles and categorial apparatus of economic science are still in existence and effect. In that part the "new economics" has not made any difference. To attach an attribute of theoretical paradigm to the "new economics" is especially thanklessly when, as well known, it significantly reduces the choice as the essence of economics, creating top competence, forcing intracompany exchange and network partnerships which, in a way, mean naturalization of commodity and monetary flows and competition limitation. From a view of practice, there is no doubt about informatics, telecommunication, innovative, organizational, globalization and other achievements and manifestations that make it "new" in a paradigmatic meaning of the word.
Key words	new economics, paradigm, network economics, information, knowledge
Literature	Аллэ, М., 1979, «Единственный критерий истины – согласие с данными опыта», Мы- ровая экономика и международные отноше- ния Но 11, 25-9. Bjelić, P., 2001, "Elektronska trgovina", Ekonomika preduzetništva No 1-2, 27-30. Dragičević, A. i Dragičević, D., 2003, Doba kiberkomunizma, Zagreb. Drašković, V., 2002, Kontrasti globalizacije, Beograd-Kotor, Ekonomika i Fakultet za pomorstvo. ____________, 2002a "Globalne strategije", Strategijski menadžment br. 4, 58-64, ____________, 2003, "Strategija virtualizacije kao proizvod nove ekonomije", Strategijski menadžment br. 1-2, 29-33. ____________, 2004, "Mrežno poslovno povezivanje kao megatrend i nova menadžment strategija", Ekonomika preduzetništva br. 2, 126- 9, ____________, 2005, "Mrežno povezivanje kao nova paradigma strategijskog upravljanja poslovnim procesima", Strategijski menadžment br. 1-2 (u štampi). Ilić, B. (2004), "Tranzicija industrijske (tradicionalne) u novu (informatičku) ekonomiju", Ekonomski anali br. 162, 99-126. Jakšić, M., 2005, "Vizija, institucije i privredni razvoj", Ekonomski anali br. 163, 63-70. Kolodko, G., 2002, "Новая экономика и старые проблемы", Проблемы теории и прак- тики управления Но 3, Kotlica, S., 2000, "E-konomija", Ekonomika preduzetništva No 7-8, 197-201. Kuhn, T., 1974, Struktura naučnih revolucija, Beograd, Nolit. Naisbitt, I., 1982, Megatrends: Ten New Directions Transforming Our Lives, New York. __________, 1985, "Megachoices: Option for Tomorrow's World", Futurist, Vol.19, No 4, Washington, 13-16. «The New Economy: Myth and Reality», Monthly Revie N 11, April 2001. Нуреев, Р., 1993, «Предпосилки новой экономической парадигми: онтология и гно- сеология», Вопросы экономики Но 4, 121-44. Toffler, A., 1980, The Third Wave, New York. Toynbee, A., 1934, Study of History , Vol. I , London, Oxford University Press. UNCTAD, 1995, World Investment Report 1995, Transnational Corporations and Competitivenes. World Bank, 1999, World Development Indicators, The World Bank.
	Download full article

Radislav Jovović

THE DISTINCS DIFFERENCES BETWEEN OLD AND EMERGING ECONOMY

Article title	THE DISTINCS DIFFERENCES BETWEEN OLD AND EMERGING ECONOMY
Authors	Radislav Jovović
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	A10, D23, D82
Abstract	This paper is focused on a new economic reality.The purpose of this paper is to contribute analysis of the fundamental shift that is taking place in economy. This shift is from the neoclassical economy to the "new economy". While changes have been happening and policy makers have made a plea for guidance in the era of new economy, scholars have been slow to respond. This paper attempts to identify and articulate differences between old and new reality in economy. We do this by contrasting the most fundamental elements of the newly emerging reality with those of the old economy. We identify the very significant departure from neoclassical economy and we can admit that the new objective of ideas is necessary to explain the real contrast two polar worlds. The common thread throughout these trade-offs is the increased role of knowledge, information and technological improvements.
Key words	New economy, information asymmetry , transaction costs, knowledge.
Literature	is not available
	Download full article

Grzegorz Kolodko

TRANSITION TO A MARKET. WHY GRADUALISM WORKS AND RADICALISM FAILS?

Article title	TRANSITION TO A MARKET. WHY GRADUALISM WORKS AND RADICALISM FAILS?
Authors	Grzegorz Kolodko
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	P20, P24
Abstract	Years after commencement of the systemic reforms in Central East Europe and the former Soviet Union the debate on the way of conducting reforms is still on. The main question remains: gradualism or radicalism? Unfortunately many countries decided to embark on a radical way of transformation which resulted in a number of cases in decrease of GDP, and consequently substantial lowering in the standard of living of their citizens. By the year 2004 many countries still have not reached the GDP level from the year 1989. Transformation, however, in its very meaning is a gradual process. It consists of three main elements: liberalisation and stabilisation; institutional building; and macroeconomic restructuring. Completion of all three processes requires time, in particular as far as institutional building and microeconomic restructuring are concerned. Poland, although unnecessarily started loosing its GDP at the beginning, recovered relatively rapidly. The economic systemic reforms here can be divided into four periods: "shock without therapy" (1989-1993), "Strategy for Poland" (1994-1997), overcooling (1998-2001) and from 2002 until now the period of accelerated growth. During realisation of the "Strategy for Poland" the country gained 28 percent in economic growth per capita, unemployment shrank from 17 to 10 percent. Results in economic performance are also dependent on the long-term development policy. The Chinese experience proves the importance of it.
Key words	is not available
Literature	is not available
	Download full article

Anđelko Lojpur

MANAGEMENT IN THE PROCESS OF THE CORPORATE GOVERNANCE

Article title	MANAGEMENT IN THE PROCESS OF THE CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
Authors	Anđelko Lojpur
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	M13, P31
Abstract	Generally, the process of privatization of former state and social enterprise in the postsocialistic countries has up to now reaffirmed institutional basis of the capitalistic model of enterprise and entrepreneurship. However, except the small number of countries, it has not resulted in adequate reform effects, more precisely; the effects are still far below the expectations of the employees even in the privatized enterprises and citizens in all.
Key words	Corporate governance, management, privatization, transition.
Literature	[1] Anderson, E.R., "Voucher Funds in The Transition Economies", the Czech and Slovak Examples, Investment Funds as Intermediaries of Privatization, CEEPN, Ljubljana, 1994. [2] Berg A.,Berg E., "Methods of Privatization", Journal of International Affairs, School of International and Public Affairs, Columbia University, vol 50/No.2. 1997. [3] Bohinc, R., "Corporate governance ", ZDA, Evropa, Slovenija, Fakulteta za družbene vede, Ljubljana, 2001. [4] Csaki, G., Macher, A., "The Ten Years of Hungarian Privatization", Budapest, June, 1998. [5] Dubiel, S., "Corporate Governance: Pushing Ahed without Best Practice", CIPE. [6] Enthoven, A., "The Enron Crisis: some Lesssons for Transition Economies", Transition, January-February. [7] Estrin, S. "Competition and corporate governance in the period of transition ", W.Davidson Institut, decembar, 2002 [8] Lojpur, A., Dragašević, M; Janković, D., "Understanding privatization ", Official Gazete of the Republic of Montenegro, Podgorica, 1999 [9] Pirie, M., "Policymaking and Privatization: Ten Lessons from Experience", Economic Reform Today, 1/1998. [10] Saliven, Dž., "Transparency between government and management", Ekonomist, Beograd, br.62., 2001. [11] "What Can Transition Economics Learn from the First 10 Years?", Transition, January-February, 2002. [12] "Guide for corporate governance", SEC, Podgorica, 2003.
	Download full article

Mimo Drašković

THEORY OF GAMES AND RESEARCH COMPANY's NATURE

Article title	THEORY OF GAMES AND RESEARCH COMPANY's NATURE
Authors	Mimo Drašković
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	C70, C71
Abstract	Company is complicate economic category and particular institute of contemporary economic system. In western economic science has been formulated different views on the nature of company. Theory of games has been arise in as alternative theoretical concept in evolution of research company's nature. There has been wide time interval between first (Cournot 1838) and next pioneer's attempt (Bertrand 1883, Edgeworth 1925) in appliance theory of games in analyse of economic problems. All those attempts had been limited on cases of oligopoly price policy and volume of production, without of possibility of generalize appliance theory of games on analyse of the other economic problems (balance, competition, risk, doubt, rationality, public choice, etc.). It was, partly, enabled in mid of last century (1944) when mathematician John Von Neumann and economist Oskar Morgenstern published book "Theory of games and economic behaviour". They analysed matrix game of two actors with zero result, what mean that profit of one player is loss for the other. They went from assuming of rational players' behaviour, internecine conflict of theirs economic interests, risk and abeyance of opposing decisions. Aim of this article is to see importance and possibility of application theory of games in companies at all, and especially in nautical companies and in ports.
Key words	company, theory of games, competition, strategy, information.
Literature	Benić, Đuro (2001), Osnovi ekonomije, Zagreb, Školska knjiga, 242-6. Coase, R. (1937), "The Nature of the Firm", Economica, Vol. 4, 386-405. Coase, R. (1988), "Lecture on the Nature of the Firm", Journal of Law, Economics and Organization, Vol. 4, 33-47. Drašković, Mimo (2003), "Brodarstvo kao uslužna privredna djelatnost", u: Zbornik Fakulteta za pomorstvo u Kotoru br. 20, 187-95. ______________ (2004), "Teorija igara u strategijskom menadžmentu brodarskih i lučkih usluga", Ekonomika preduzetništva br. 1, 63-7. Jakšić, Momir (1993), "Teorija igara u ekonomiji", Ekonomika br. 3, 73-4. Prica, Ivana (1995), "Teorija igara kao osnov za razumevanje složenih ekonomskih pitanja", Ekonomika br. 1-2, 58-9. Rozanova, N. (2002), "Evoljucija vzgljadov na prirodu firmi v zapadnoj ekonomičeskoj nauke", Voprosi ekonomiki br. 1, 50-67. Samuelson, A. P. i Nordhaus, D. W. (1997), Ekonomika, Moskva, Binom-KnoRus, 232-41. Simon, H. (1975), "Behavioral Model of Rational Choice", Quarterly Journal of Economica No 10, 99-118. Stojanović, Božo (1995), "Teorija igara u kontekstu metodoloških problema ekonomske nauke", Ekonomski anali br. 124, 57-75. Sutton, J. (1991), Sunk Costs and Market Structure, MIT Press. Sutton, J. (1998), Technology and market Structure, MIT Press.
	Download full article

Jože Mencinger

THE SLOVENIAN TRANSITION MODEL

Article title	THE SLOVENIAN TRANSITION MODEL
Authors	Jože Mencinger
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	P20, P21
Abstract	The transition in Slovenia has been described as gradualist. Indeed, gradualism was, in a sense, a natural heritage of previous systemic changes, embodied in the country's initial economic conditions and consistent with its political history. Amidst political uncertainty in 1990, the Slovenian government decided to pursue pragmatic economic policy which should ascertain the socially bearable costs of transition, facilitate timely adaptation to highly uncertain political decisions, and generate suitable responses to the economic policies of the federal government. Systemic changes were made cautiously as well. The fact that gradualism prevailed in Slovenia's macroeconomic policy and systemic restructuring does not imply that there was a general consensus. On the contrary. Gradualism implied that certain rather specific political, social, and economic features should be used in the transition. This became a disputed issue: the majority of domestic economists considered the legacy of the past an exploitable advantage; to many foreign and a minority of domestic economists, however, it would impede rather than assist the transition.
Key words	is not available
Literature	Bomhoff, E. J. 1992. "Monetary Reform in Eastern Europe." European Economic Review 36(April): 454-58. Hanke, S. H., and K. Schuler. 1991. "Monetary Reform and the Development of a Yugoslav Market Economy." New Series 3. Center for Research Into Communist Economies. London. Meltzer, A. H. 1992. "Prices and Wages in Transition to a Market Economy." Paper presented at the 19th Karl Brunner Symposium on Liberty, Analysis, and Ideology, Interlaken, Switzerland, June 8-12. Mencinger, J. 1991. "From Socialism to Capitalism and from Dependence to Independence (Double Transition of Slovenia)." Est-Ovest 22 (December): 57-92. ---------. 1994. "The Birth and the Childhood of a Currency: The Experience of Slovenia". In J. Gacs, ed., International Trade and Restructuring in Eastern.
	Download full article

Života Ristić

BANKARSTVO EU I SCG - KONGRUENTNOST I KOMPATIBILNOST -

Article title	BANKARSTVO EU I SCG - KONGRUENTNOST I KOMPATIBILNOST -
Authors	Života Ristić
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	G21, E58
Abstract	In the contemporary banking trade the most development countries in the world, it is totally unattended conservative banking, so that institutional-organizational form has minority role. In this article it is analyzed congregation and compatibility of banking in SCG with banking of the most development trade economies, primarily in USA and EU, and from the functional aspect (portfolio of investment) of those systems, and not from aspect of their organization-institutional structure.
Key words	Banking, bank, directive EU, multinational bank, trade oblige limit.
Literature	is not available
	Download full article

Ростислав Капелюшников, Наталия Демина

ОБНОВЛЕНИЕ ВЫСШЕГО МЕНЕДЖМЕНТА РОССИЙСКИХ ПРОМЫШЛЕННЫХ ПРЕДПРИЯТИЙ:ИНТЕНСИВНОСТЬ, КАНАЛЫ ПОПОЛНЕНИЯ, ОСНОВНЫЕ ОПРЕДЕЛЯЮЩИЕ ФАКТОРЫ

Article title	ОБНОВЛЕНИЕ ВЫСШЕГО МЕНЕДЖМЕНТА РОССИЙСКИХ ПРОМЫШЛЕННЫХ ПРЕДПРИЯТИЙ:ИНТЕНСИВНОСТЬ, КАНАЛЫ ПОПОЛНЕНИЯ, ОСНОВНЫЕ ОПРЕДЕЛЯЮЩИЕ ФАКТОРЫ
Authors	Ростислав Капелюшников, Наталия Демина
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	P30, D23
Abstract	In this article is analyzed, descriptive and economic, general institutional tendencies and lawfulness which characterized dynamics of high managers of the Russian industry in the period after privatisation, as concrete impression factors. Russian industry is characterized by paradoxical combination between high participation of the executives from "old"nomenclature and high level of yearly repeated of directorial corps. Insider's belonging reinforce position of higher managers, in contrast to outsider's belongings'. There is converse dependence between frequency of relays of higher managers and results of economic activities of the company by which one they manage. In spite of that slow moving, which interlock expand insider belongs', and many other deviations, the process of selection and affirmation of relatively efficient managers is unstoppable. It contributes to development of Russian system corporative management.
Key words	institutions, corporative management, property, actions, internal and external shareholders.
Literature	is not available
	Download full article

Роман Качалов

ОПЕРАЦИОНАЛЬНЫЙ ПОДХОД В ИССЛЕДОВАНИИ ЭКОНОМИЧЕСКОГО РИСКА

Article title	ОПЕРАЦИОНАЛЬНЫЙ ПОДХОД В ИССЛЕДОВАНИИ ЭКОНОМИЧЕСКОГО РИСКА
Authors	Роман Качалов
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	D81
Abstract	Theory of controlling of economic risk, especially on the level of the enterprise, characterizes furlough of conventional and consistent systems of general notion about object and about instruments of research. This article try to recommend solution of above mentioned problems
Key words	economic risk, incertitude, enterprise, theory of controlling, factors of economic risk
Literature	is not available
	Download full article

Юрий Осипов

ЧТО ЕСТЬ ЭКОНОМИКА ВООБЩЕ И ЧТО ОНА ЕСТЬ СЕГОДНЯ

Article title	ЧТО ЕСТЬ ЭКОНОМИКА ВООБЩЕ И ЧТО ОНА ЕСТЬ СЕГОДНЯ
Authors	Юрий Осипов
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	A10, P00
Abstract	In this article from the aspect of the economic's philosophy, on untraditional way, is demonstrated difference between economy as human life's activity and economic as its separate case, and all that from the prism of static and dynamic and especially money as dominant principle. By elaboration relations of economic and non economic, "economic from above" and "economic from below", it is becoming known institute of economic freedoms, which is being disorganized in practice with domination policy over economy. In those relations, decisive role (in some post socialist states where as well Russia belongs) has government echelons, which realize "economic from above". "Economic from above" do not serve to "economic from below", how post social liberals- marketers see that, but "those below" with enthusiasm support "crown", how it is well known to bandmaster –globalist. It must be considered that economic is not economy, but control under economy as specific institute which enable its governablity.
Key words	economy, money, price, power.
Literature	is not available
	Download full article

Дмитрий Сорокин

РОССИЯ НА ПОЛИТЭКОНОМИЧЕСКОЙ КАРТЕ МИРА

Article title	РОССИЯ НА ПОЛИТЭКОНОМИЧЕСКОЙ КАРТЕ МИРА
Authors	Дмитрий Сорокин
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	P51
Abstract	Globalization caused that present and future socio-economic reality of the states depends from their place in global economy, accordingly from that character of involving in itself. There is no alternative for resources' disposal fluctuation and economy openness. In this article, it is analyzed strategic aspect of the Russia under the condition of globalization.
Key words	globalization, economy, resources, strategy.
Literature	is not available
	Download full article

Александр Худокормов

O ЗАКОНAХ ИСТОРИИ ЭКОНОМИЧЕСКОЙ МЫСЛИ

Article title	O ЗАКОНAХ ИСТОРИИ ЭКОНОМИЧЕСКОЙ МЫСЛИ
Authors	Александр Худокормов
Category	Economics
Article type	Science Article	JEL Classification	B20, B24
Abstract	In this article from the aspect of the economic's philosophy, on untraditional way, is demonstrated difference between economy as human life's activity and economic as its separate case, and all that from the prism of static and dynamic and especially money as dominant principle. By elaboration relations of economic and non economic, "economic from above" and "economic from below", it is becoming known institute of economic freedoms, which is being disorganized in practice with domination policy over economy. In those relations, decisive role (in some post socialist states where as well Russia belongs) has government echelons, which realize "economic from above". "Economic from above" do not serve to "economic from below", how post social liberals- marketers see that, but "those below" with enthusiasm support "crown", how it is well known to bandmaster –globalist. It must be considered that economic is not economy, but control under economy as specific institute which enable its governablity.
Key words	lows of the history economic thoughts, economic theory, Marxism crisis, unconstitutional, social market economy.
Literature	is not available
	Download full article